Most ecommerce brands treat Black Friday Cyber Monday like a revenue sprint. They pour budget into acquisition, hit their sales target, and move on. A month later, they wonder why retention is flat and why so few of those new customers came back.

The problem is not the discount. The problem is what happens after the sale.

While existing customers also shop with more intend during BFCM, BFCM also brings a flood of impulse buyers that have never purchased from you before. People who were not looking for your brand specifically. People who clicked because the price was right or the ad caught them at the right moment. These customers are valuable, but only if you convert them from one-time buyers into repeat purchasers.

The brands that win long term are not the ones that drive the most BFCM revenue. They are the ones that turn November deal hunters into customers who reorder in January, March, and beyond. That conversion does not happen by accident. It happens because you built a system to make it happen.

Want to connect?
Connect w/ Me On LinkedIn!

Why BFCM Customers Are Different

Net new BFCM customers behave differently than customers acquired during the rest of the year. They are driven by urgency and price. They are comparison shopping across dozens of brands. They have lower brand loyalty at the point of purchase because the deal is what pulled them in, not your story or product differentiation.

This does not mean they are bad customers. It means they need a different onboarding strategy. If you treat them the same way you treat someone who found you organically in March and paid full price, you will lose most of them.

The first 30 days after their BFCM purchase determine whether they become repeat buyers or disappear. That window is everything.

Start with the Post-Purchase Experience

Retention starts the moment someone completes checkout. Most brands waste this moment by showing a generic thank you page and sending a boring order confirmation email. That is a missed opportunity to set expectations, build trust, and start the relationship on the right foot.

Your thank you page should do more than confirm the order. Use it to tell the customer what happens next. When will the product ship. When will it arrive. What should they expect when they open the box. If the product requires any setup or has a learning curve, give them a preview so they feel prepared.

Include a clear call to action. This could be following your social accounts, joining a community, or downloading a guide that helps them get more value from the product. The goal is to keep them engaged while they wait for the product to arrive.

Your order confirmation email should reinforce the same information. Shipping timeline, tracking link, and a reminder of what they bought and why it matters. If the product has common use cases or tips, include a link to a resource that helps them get started. Do not try to sell them something else yet. Just make sure they feel confident about what they purchased.

The First Email Flow: Onboarding, Not Selling

After the product ships, your first email flow should focus on onboarding, not upselling. BFCM buyers do not know your brand yet. They do not trust you yet. If you immediately try to sell them something else, you look like every other transactional brand that only cares about the next order.

Send a sequence that builds trust and teaches them how to use what they bought. Email one arrives when the product is delivered. Confirm delivery, thank them, and give a single tip or use case to help them get started. Email two comes three to five days later. Share a common mistake people make with the product or a way to maximize results. Email three lands a week after that. Include a testimonial or case study from someone who got great results, and invite them to share their own experience or ask a question.

This sequence does two things. It increases the chance they actually use the product, which is the strongest driver of repeat purchase. And it positions your brand as helpful and invested in their success, not just transactional.

At the end of this flow, you can introduce a replenishment offer or a complementary product, but only after you have delivered value first. The sequence is value, value, value, then offer. Not offer, offer, offer.

Segment BFCM Buyers Separately

Do not lump net new BFCM customers into your general email list. Create a dedicated segment so you can message them differently. These customers came in on a discount, so their perception of your pricing is anchored to that lower number. If you immediately send them full-price offers in January, the sticker shock will hurt conversion.

Instead, ease them into full price. Send educational content first. Then introduce products at a modest discount or bundle that feels like a deal without tanking margin. Over time, as they experience the product and build trust, they will be more willing to pay full price. But that transition takes weeks, not days.

Segmenting also lets you track retention metrics separately. You can measure how many BFCM customers place a second order within 60 days, 90 days, and six months. That data tells you whether your retention strategy is working or whether you are just churning through one-time buyers.

Use Replenishment Timing to Your Advantage

If you sell consumables like supplements, skincare, coffee, or pet products, replenishment timing is your biggest retention lever. Most BFCM buyers do not think about reordering until they run out. By then, they have forgotten about your brand and are shopping around again.

Calculate the average time it takes for someone to use up the product. Then send a replenishment reminder a week before they are likely to run out. The email should feel helpful, not pushy. Remind them they are probably getting low, make reordering easy with a direct link to the product, and offer a modest incentive if needed to close the deal.

If your product is not a consumable, look for logical next purchases. Someone who bought a yoga mat might need blocks or a strap. Someone who bought a kitchen gadget might need a complementary tool. Map out the natural purchase progression and time your emails accordingly.

The key is relevance and timing. Send the right offer at the moment when the customer is most likely to need it. That is how you turn a one-time buyer into a repeat customer.

Loyalty Programs and Memberships Accelerate Retention

BFCM is a good time to introduce loyalty programs or paid memberships to new customers. Someone who just made their first purchase is thinking about your brand. If you present a clear, valuable reason to join a program that rewards repeat purchases, a percentage will opt in.

For free loyalty programs, make the value obvious. Points for every purchase, early access to sales, birthday discounts. Keep it simple and make sure customers can see their balance and rewards easily in their account.

For paid memberships, the value needs to be immediate and repeatable. Free shipping, exclusive discounts, or members-only products work well. If the membership pays for itself in two or three orders, customers will join. And once they are paying to be a member, they are much more likely to consolidate their purchases with you instead of shopping around.

The best time to pitch a membership is right after someone places their second order. They have already come back once, which signals intent. A well-timed membership offer at that moment converts at a much higher rate than trying to sell it to a first-time buyer.

Measure What Matters

The metric that matters most is second purchase rate. What percentage of BFCM customers place a second order within 60 days. Within 90 days. Within six months. If that number is low, your retention system is not working.

Track this separately from your overall customer base. BFCM cohorts will always have different behavior than customers acquired at full price, so do not blend the data. Measure the cohort on its own and compare year over year to see if your retention tactics are improving.

Also track email engagement for your BFCM segment. Open rates, click rates, and conversion rates on your post-purchase flows. If engagement is low, your emails are not resonating. Test different subject lines, content angles, and offers until you find what works.

Finally, measure lifetime value by acquisition cohort. Calculate the LTV of customers acquired during BFCM 2024 versus BFCM 2023. If LTV is increasing, your retention improvements are working. If not, you are still treating BFCM like a one-time revenue event instead of a customer acquisition opportunity.

Why This Matters for Long-Term Growth

Turning BFCM buyers into repeat customers changes the economics of your entire business. If you can increase second purchase rate from 15% to 25%, you just made every BFCM dollar you spent on acquisition significantly more valuable. Higher repeat rates mean higher LTV, which means you can afford to pay more to acquire customers, which means you can scale faster.

It also reduces your dependence on paid acquisition. Brands that retain well can grow through repeat purchases and word of mouth instead of constantly pouring money into new customer acquisition. That makes the business more profitable, more stable, and more valuable if you ever sell.

The brands that treat BFCM as a customer acquisition event instead of just a revenue event are the ones that compound growth year after year. They do not chase new customers every quarter. They build a base of repeat buyers who keep coming back.

The Bottom Line

BFCM is not just about hitting a revenue number. It is about acquiring customers who will stick around. Most brands lose those customers because they do not have a retention system in place. They treat BFCM buyers the same way they treat everyone else, and it does not work.

The fix is straightforward. Build a post-purchase experience that sets expectations and builds trust. Send an onboarding email flow that teaches instead of sells. Segment BFCM buyers so you can message them appropriately. Use replenishment timing and logical next purchases to drive second orders. Introduce loyalty programs or memberships to accelerate repeat behavior. And measure second purchase rate so you know if it is working.

Do this right, and your BFCM customers become the foundation of your growth for the next year. Skip it, and you just rented revenue that disappears by February.

Share your numbers
What is your second purchase rate for BFCM customers? How long does it take on average for them to reorder? Share your retention data so other readers can benchmark.

→ Submit to the Ecom Heads form

Talk soon,

John Sciacchitano

Ecom Heads: Scale or Die Trying

Want to connect?
Connect w/ Me On LinkedIn!