UGC vs Brand Creative in Ads

We set up a direct test: user-generated content (UGC) ads versus polished, produced video for the same offer. Same length, same placements, same call-to-action. Only the creative style changed.

Results

The difference was not small. UGC outperformed produced video on Meta with a 24% lower CPA. Same targeting, same budgets, but a clear win for creator-led assets. This result has been consistent across multiple ad sets, which means it is more than just an isolated incident.

Want to connect?
Connect w/ Me On LinkedIn!

Why UGC Works in Paid Social

Customers do not open social apps to watch commercials. They come for connection, entertainment, and quick hits of relatability. UGC taps into that pattern. It blends into the feed instead of standing out as an ad. The tone is casual, the production is light, and the delivery feels like a peer recommendation rather than a polished sales pitch.

This has downstream effects on the entire funnel. Thumb-stop rates rise because the ad looks and feels like content users already consume. Higher engagement signals improve CPM. Better efficiency at the top cascades down to lower CPC and ultimately lower CPA. By contrast, a glossy video can look out of place in the feed, even if it tells the brand story well.

What Makes a Good UGC Video for Meta Ads

• Strong hook in the first 3 seconds - Grab attention fast with a bold claim, a clear problem, or a “you need to see this” setup.
• Relatable storytelling - Keep language natural, like you would text a friend. “I did not think this would work, but...” beats “Introducing our new solution.”
• Clear demonstration - Show the product in use solving the problem. Static holding shots rarely perform.
• Authentic tone - Slight imperfections help. Phone camera, natural light, casual setting - these increase believability. Overly polished UGC loses the trust signal.
• Direct call-to-action - End with a concrete reason to click. Vague endings lose momentum.

When sourcing UGC, you do not need the biggest influencers. You need creators who can deliver genuine energy on camera and produce content that looks like what your customer already watches in their feed.

What This Means for Creative Strategy

The takeaway is clear. UGC has earned its place as the default format for prospecting. We are shifting more spend toward UGC-based campaigns for Q4. Competition will be high, CPMs will rise, and the teams that win will test and refresh creative at scale. UGC gives us that flexibility. We can brief creators quickly, get raw content back in days, and iterate multiple variations without heavy production costs.

Produced content still has a role, but it moves further down the funnel. It works in remarketing where customers already know the brand, and on owned channels where polish supports trust. In paid prospecting, authenticity beats perfection.

Practical Execution Notes

• Briefing creators - Provide context and key points, then let them use their own voice. Over-scripted UGC underperforms.
• Spark Ads - When possible, run content from the creator’s handle. The social proof is stronger.
• Formats to test - Reactions, unboxings, “I tried this so you do not have to,” quick tutorials, and problem-solution stories.
• Production trade-offs - Do not chase studio perfection. Minor imperfections often lift performance.

How We Are Applying This in Q4

We are allocating more of our Q4 budget to UGC prospecting while using produced assets for brand storytelling and evergreen placements. Our pipeline targets at least two new UGC concepts each week, with multiple cuts per concept for testing. Produced videos still run in remarketing, on PDPs, and in email where polish confirms credibility.

This split maximizes impact. UGC fills the top of the funnel with cheaper acquisition, while produced content closes the loop later. In practice, that means scaling faster while keeping CPA under control during the most competitive quarter of the year.

Why This Matters Beyond CPA

Lower CPA is the headline, but the ripple effects matter. Higher thumb-stop rates build stronger engagement signals that improve the account overall. More efficient prospecting budgets let us reinvest into remarketing and LTV programs. Most importantly, running UGC at scale forces creative to operate at platform speed - that adaptability is now a competitive advantage.

Talk soon,

John Sciacchitano

Ecom Heads: Scale or Die Trying

Want to connect?
Connect w/ Me On LinkedIn!